After 8pm, agents go quiet: what 154 mystery-shopped enquiries found
By Kerfuffle Editorial ·
Stitch Ai and Institution Marketing posed as sellers and buyers and sent 154 enquiries to agencies in London, Birmingham and Newcastle. Nearly a third never heard from a person.
Agencies spend a fortune getting the phone to ring. A new mystery shop asks what happens after it does.
In October, Stitch Ai and Institution Marketing sent 154 enquiries to estate agency branches: 90 valuation requests through agency websites and 64 viewing requests through Rightmove. They then logged every call, text and email that came back over the following week. No agency is named.
The headline numbers
47 of the 154 enquiries (31%) got no human contact at all. That was 31 of 90 sellers and 16 of 64 buyers.
The evening was the weak spot. Of 35 valuation requests sent between 8pm and 10pm, just 2 got a reply from a person that night. Every one of the 214 calls agents made to the test number landed between 08:28 and 18:51.
Sellers also waited longest. The median time to first contact on a valuation request was 5 hours 13 minutes, against 1 hour 28 minutes for a viewing request. Only 2 of the 90 sellers heard from a person within an hour. The researchers point out that the seller forms all went in out of hours and the buyer ones during the working day, so timing explains a lot of that gap.
Auto-replies and missed calls
44 enquiries got an automated reply, almost all within a minute. None of the 28 sent to sellers offered a valuation slot, and none in either round said when someone would call.
The test number never answered, so every agent call was missed. Of the 87 agencies that phoned, only 9 tried again within the hour, and 23 rang once and gave up. Not one of the 154 enquiries got a WhatsApp message, and only six agencies sent a personal text.
What agents can take from it
The report's suggestions are practical: treat the evening as part of the working day, make the first reply start a conversation rather than just acknowledge it, clear overnight leads before 9am, follow a missed call with a written message, and mystery-shop your own branches.
As the report puts it: "Speed to first response matters. Speed to a meaningful conversation is worth more."
The full findings, charts and a 12-minute video walkthrough from Stitch Ai founder Paul Gandar are free to read and embed: Stitch Ai estate agent response times 2026.
See Stitch Ai on Kerfuffle.
Source: Stitch Ai estate agency mystery shop, October 2026.